Skip to Main Content
It looks like you're using Internet Explorer 11 or older. This website works best with modern browsers such as the latest versions of Chrome, Firefox, Safari, and Edge. If you continue with this browser, you may see unexpected results.

Research Help: Journal Articles

Articles: evaluate based on Scholarly vs. Popular

Articles:

Scholarly and Popular

Scholarly

vs.

Popular

Image credit: Cmlitstudies on Wikimedia Commons

 

Image credit: tanakawho on Flickr

Usually written by an scholar or a researcher in the field. Credentials and/or affiliation are given.

Author

Often a professional writer with no expertise in the subject area. Author's name may or may not be given.

Other scholars, researchers and students.

Audience

The general public; interested amateurs

Specialized terminology or jargon; requires prior knowledge.

Language

General vocabulary. Understandable to most readers.

Articles have a defined structure with an abstract, objective, methodology, results, analysis, conclusion and references.

Appearance

Informal organization, usually eye catching. Typically contains photographs.

Always provides a list of references or a bibliography. Sources are cited and can be verified.

References/ Bibliography

Rarely has a list of references, if they do, they usually do not give complete information about sources.

Articles are peer-reviewed before publication by a panel of researchers for accuracy, methodology and importance.

Peer-Review

 

No peer-review process, review process is through a non-expert editor.

Effect of Caffeine on Prospective and Retrospective Duration Judgments

Example

Better Learning Through Fidgeting